PAKISTAN STEEL
BULK MATERIAL DEPARTMENT
BID EVALUATION REPORT
TECHNO ECONOMIC EVALUATION, CARRIED OUT THROUGH COMPUTER RUN FOR PROCUREMENT OF 150,000 MT IRON ORE FINE (+10%)
Tender Enquiry No: BMD/64/I.O.F./08 TENDER OPENING / TECHNICAL SCRUTINY DATE :  18.07.2008
Mode of Tendering: NEGOTIATED Commercial Bids Opening date: 24.07.2008
Displayed on Websites of Pakistan Steel & PPRA on 11.07.2008 No. of Financial Bids Evaluated: 02
No. of Offers received: 04  Quantity: 150,000MT (+10%)
Disqualified Offers:  02
No:of bidders Technically qualified: 03
S.NO: NAME OF PARTICIPANT/  BIDDER GRADE OF OFFERED ORE PERCENTAGE CONTENTS OF ELEMENTS REQUIRED & OFFERED AGAINST OUR PRESS TENDER SPECIFICATION SIZE ANALYSIS (AT DISCHARGE PORT) OFFER VALIDITY HOT METAL COST (RS.) POSITION
Fe (T) (%) Si02 (%) Al203  (%)     S    (%)       P     (%)     Cu     (%)      Ti02      (%)     MgO  (%)     CaO    (%) MNO (%) LOI (%) Alkali (%) Moist.  (%) Other elements like Zn, Pb, Cr, Sn, V etc. % (+) 10MM % (-) 10MM (+) 6MM    % (-) 0.15% 100 Mesh (+)0.15MM to (-) 6MM %
FINE 57.00 (min) 8.50 (max) 2.50 0.05  (max) 0.10  (max) 0.05 (max) As low as possible - - - - As low as possible 7.00 (max) In Traces    5.00   (max) 15.00 (max) 35.00 (max) Remainder
1 M/S NEW INDIA MINNING CORP LTD INDIA C/O METATEC ENGG SERVICES GTD 61.0 3.0 3.0 0.05 0.065 trace 0.2 trace trace 5.0 Trace 7.0 Trace 5 15 35 rem As per tender 38155.16 1st Lowest
TYP 62.0 3.0 2.5 0.04 0.06 trace trace trace trace trace 4.0 Trace 6.5 Trace 5 15 35 rem
2 M/S MINERAL ENTERPRISES LTD   C/O AJCL GTD 61.00 7.5 3.5 0.03 0.1 trace trace trace trace - 5.0 Trace 11.0 Trace 10 15 35 rem 30 days   (both for FOBT & Freight) 38227.34 2nd lowest
TYP 61.30 5.0 2.85 0.03 0.06 trace trace trace trace - 4.0 - 10.2 Trace 9 15 30 rem