PAKISTAN STEEL
	BULK MATERIAL DEPARTMENT
	BID EVALUATION REPORT
	PREQUALIFIED BIDDERS OF METALLURGICAL COKE PARTICIPATED AGAINST OUR PUBLIC TENDER NOTICE APPEARED ON WEBSITE OF PAKISTAN STEEL                                                                                                                           ON 09.07.2008 AND ALSO IN THE LEADING DAILIES OF COUNTRY ON 13.07.2008, OPENED BY TECHNICAL SCRUTINY COMMITTEE (TSC) ON 12.08.2008 AND                                                                                                                                                        "FINANCIAL PROPOSAL" OPENED ON 19.08.2008, ITS TECHNO ECONOMIC EVALUATION, IS CARRIED OUT THROUGH COMPUTER RUN PROCESS FOR                                                                                                                                                                                         QUALITY ADJUSTED PRICE FOR PROCUREMENT OF 40,000MT MET.COKE (+10%)
	Tender Enquiry No: BMD/63/MET.COKE/08																TENDER OPENING DATE :  12.08.2008
	Mode of Tendering THROUGH WEBSITES &  PRESS TENDER																Financial Proposal  Opening date: 19.08.2008
	No. of Offers received:06																No. of Financial Bids Evaluated: 05
	Technically Disqualified: 01																Quantity: 40,000MT (+10%)
	No:of bidders Technically pre-qualified: 05
	S.NO:	BIDDER'S NAME	TENDER SPECIFICATION											QUOTED RATE       US$ / PDMT			QUALITY ADJUSTED PRICE US$/ PDMT		REMARKS
			Moisture%	Ash           %	Volatile Matter %	Sulphur%	Phospho-      rous %	Alkalis %	M 40	M10	(+)       80mm	(-)          30mm	Mean size	FOBT	Freight	CFFO	FOBT	CFFO
			5 (MAX)	12.50 (max)	1.50 (max)	0.70 (max)	0.07 (max)	0.17 (max)	78      (min)	08  (max)	10% (max)	05% (max)	48 mm (min)
	1	M/s. IMR Metallurgucal Resources AG, Switzerland	05%	12.00%	0.80%	0.60%	0.04%	0.17%	78	6.5	10%	05%	48 mm	686.90	35.00	721.90	681.06	716.06	1ST LOWEST
		Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	(-)2.50	(-) 0.84	(-) 2.50	-	-	-	-		-	-
		Freight Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-		-	-
	2	M/s Noble Resources, Singapore,	05%	12.50%	1.00%	0.65%	0.07%	0.17%	78	08	10%	05%	48 mm	669.00	54.00	723.00	667.15	721.15	--------
		Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	-	(-) 0.60	(-) 1.25	-	-	-	-		-	-
		Freight Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-		-	-
	3	M/s Metallurgy & Chemistry Product Ltd., Dubai.	05%	12.50%	1.0%	0.5%	0.06%	0.17%	78	08	10%	05%	48 mm	662.00	83.00	745.00	656.40	739.40	--------
		Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	-	(-) 0.60	(-)5.00	-	-	-	-		-	-
		Freight Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-		-	-
	4	M/s Visa Comtrade AG, Switzerland	05%	12.00%	0.80%	0.65%	0.07%	0.17%	78	08	10%	05%	48 mm	700.00	51.75	751.75	695.41	747.16	--------
		Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	(-)2.50	(-) 0.84	(-) 1.25	-	-	-	-		-	-
		Freight Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-		-	-
	5	M/s Oxbow Coal BV, Netherland	05%	12.00%	0.80%	0.65%	0.035%	0.17%	80	08	10%	05%	48 mm	695.95	68.75	764.70	691.36	760.11	--------
		Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	(-)2.50	(-) 0.84	(-) 1.25	-	-	-	-		-	-
		Freight Penalties(+) / Premium(-)	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-		-	-